My old Nalgene bottles are just fine, thank you
I’ve always been skeptical of health-related fads, frenzies and hysteria. You won’t find me going out of my way to purchase anti-oxidant foods, for example. Just eat fresh food, I say. And you won’t find me quitting my Diet Coke habit because some crazies think that aspartame is going to kill me.
If I reacted to every single report that this or that is healthy – or bad for me, or might prolong my life, or shorten it, or dwell on the fact that, as some studies show, certain people may benefit from it at certain times of the day, when combined with a healthy lifestyle and exercise (tongue firmly in cheek) – I would no time left in the day.
And so the latest plastic hysteria comes to an end. The NY Times published a great piece on 10 Things to Scratch From your Worry List. See #6 in the list and note the last paragraph…
From NY Times:
6. Toxic plastic bottles. For years panels of experts repeatedly approved the use of bisphenol-a,
or BPA, which is used in polycarbonate bottles and many other plastic
products. Yes, it could be harmful if given in huge doses to rodents,
but so can the natural chemicals in countless foods we eat every day.
Dose makes the poison.But this year, after a campaign by a few researchers and activists, one federal panel expressed some concern about BPA in baby bottles. Panic ensued. Even though there was zero evidence of harm to humans,
Wal-Mart pulled BPA-containing products from its shelves, and
politicians began talking about BPA bans. Some experts fear product
recalls that could make this the most expensive health scare in
history.Nalgene has already announced that it will take BPA
out of its wonderfully sturdy water bottles. Given the publicity, the
company probably had no choice. But my old blue-capped Nalgene bottle,
the one with BPA that survived glaciers, jungles and deserts, is still
sitting right next to me, filled with drinking water. If they ever try
recalling it, they’ll have to pry it from my cold dead fingers.
Just because the NY times publishes it doesn’t mean its true.
True, true… but when it’s backed up by the scientific community and independent government agencies, I tend to believe it.
Clearly you are not following this science.
It’s not a question of a few scientists and advocates. Hundreds of studies have been published in the peer reviewed literature that raise questions about the risks of bisphenol A… the stuff that leaches out of your bottles. HUNDREDS. At levels relevant to human exposure.
So what are you going to tell your wife and your children? Gosh… this is total bullshit. Despite the multiple replicated studies that show BPA can cause harm? All these NIH funded scientists don’t know what they are doing? My knowledge from political science trumps their scientific expertise?
Good luck. Regrets to your children. Did they really sign up with someone who is ignorant about the scientific process?
Chill. No need for the harsh language. And I don’t have children. Sheesh…